Amazon FBA Updates · November 2026
Amazon Customized Grading: Set Your Own Rules for FBA Returns
Amazon now lets US FBA sellers submit their own criteria for grading returned units. The rules cover seal, packaging, accessories, authenticity and function, and you add them in Seller Central.
Amazon announced customized grading in Seller Forums in October 2026. It lets you tell Amazon what “sellable as new” means for your products, so an opened box with a broken seal may be less likely to go back on sale as new. Amazon treats your rules as guidance during grading, so they cannot force a result.
Key Takeaways
- Since October 2026, US FBA sellers can submit their own criteria for grading returns, for one ASIN or for many, including by CSV upload.
- ASINs without a rule keep Amazon’s default grading.
- FBA Grade and Resell is now called Sell as Used, and Refurbishment is now Restore to New. Both sit inside a program called Grade and Resell.
- Restore to New now carries the same $1.50 to $4.10 processing fee as Sell as Used, charged only when a unit is relisted. For sellers already enrolled, it started September 30, 2026.
What Amazon Customized Grading Changes
When a customer returns a unit, Amazon evaluates whether it can be resold as new. Customized grading adds your input to that step. You submit criteria by category, and inside each category you create rules for specific ASINs. Amazon then considers your criteria alongside its standard process for those ASINs in applicable categories.
The feature applies to selling in the United States, according to Amazon’s customized grading help page. Amazon’s pages state no seller-type requirement and do not mention Brand Registry.
Amazon also lets you give instructions on when to use Restore to New and Sell as Used for returns that cannot be sold as new. Used-price percentages you already set apply to units relisted as used if you are enrolled in Grade and Resell.
How Amazon Grades an FBA Return Today
Every FBA customer return is first judged sellable or unsellable as new. Amazon’s value recovery page lists what happens next:
- A return judged sellable as new goes back into your sellable inventory.
- A return judged unsellable goes to second-pass grading under Restore to New, if you are enrolled.
- A return that still cannot be restored goes to Sell as Used, if you are enrolled.
- Anything left goes to your unfulfillable inventory settings: removal, disposal, liquidation or donation.
Sell as Used only applies to units Amazon has already judged unsellable as new, so it does not replace the first check. Basic repackaging of eligible returns happens automatically and cannot be turned off in your settings. Restore to New is optional.
If the damage is Amazon’s fault, Amazon reimburses you and takes ownership of the unit, which it handles through its own alternate channels. Units damaged for seller-fault reasons go to your unfulfillable inventory. For the cost of each of those unsellable paths, see the FBA returns report guide.
What You Can Set in Amazon Customized Grading Rules
Amazon groups the criteria into five attributes. The examples in the third column are ours, not Amazon’s.
| Attribute | What you set | Example rule (editorial) |
|---|---|---|
| Seal and packaging | Acceptable seal and packaging conditions for resale | A sealed supplement bottle with a broken shrink band cannot be resold as new |
| Included accessories | The items that must be present | A charger and cable must both be in the box |
| Product authenticity indicators | The markers graders check to confirm the item is genuine | A hologram sticker must be present |
| Device capabilities | Functional tests the product must pass | The device powers on |
| Other capabilities | Other grading requirements or handling instructions | Units with a missing manual are sold as used |
In our view, the seal and packaging rule is the closest fit for opened returns. It asks you to pick the seal type and packaging type, and whether units can be resold as new if only the seal is broken. It also lets you say whether a unit with a broken seal or damaged packaging can be resealed or repackaged to restore it to new, or resold as used.
These are editorial examples, and Amazon does not say how rules should be written for any seller type. A private label owner with a manufacturer seal can answer that a unit with only a broken seal should not be resold as new, and Amazon treats that answer as guidance. A wholesale buyer who gets sealed cases from a distributor can apply the same rule to the SKUs where an opened box has led to complaints. An online arbitrage or retail arbitrage reseller can write a rule only for items where the retailer’s packaging is the proof of condition.
Three limits apply:
- Only one rule per category applies to an ASIN at a time, and a new rule for an ASIN that already has one replaces the old rule.
- One seal and packaging rule covers only ASINs that share the same seal type and packaging type. ASINs with different types need separate rules.
- A rule applies only to the ASINs it lists.
How to Set Up Amazon Customized Grading Rules
- In Seller Central, go to Settings, then Orders, then Recovery, then Customized grading.
- Select Manage on an attribute, such as Seal and packaging, and select Add new rule.
- Under Applicable ASINs, choose all ASINs in your catalog, type or paste a list separated by commas or line breaks, or upload a CSV using Amazon’s template and select Upload.
- Under Grading criteria, pick the seal type and packaging type, and answer whether the ASINs can be resold as new if only the seal is broken. Add any extra seal and packaging requirements if you need them.
- Set whether items with a broken seal or damaged packaging can be resealed or repackaged to restore to new, or resold as used.
- Select Save & Close or Finish. To add another rule in the same attribute, select Save and add another rule.
- Repeat for the other attributes.
To check your rules later, open the attribute page. It lists each rule with its criteria, a rule summary, the number of ASINs and available actions. You can search by ASIN, filter by seal type, packaging type or rule, view a rule’s details, add or remove ASINs, and download the table.
Amazon Sell as Used and Restore to New Fees and Settings
Amazon’s help pages now call the old FBA Grade and Resell service Sell as Used, and the old Refurbishment service Restore to New. Grade and Resell is the program name for both. Your existing enrollment and settings carry over, both services stay opt-in, and you can change them at any time without enrolling again.
Enrollment is in your automated value recovery settings. For Sell as Used you can enroll the whole catalog and exclude up to 2,000 ASINs, or enroll select ASINs. You set the recovery percentage for each used condition, and automatic price adjustments, which keep the used price tied to the new price, are on by default.
Both services use the same per-unit processing fee. It is charged once per item, only when the item is relisted as new or used:
| Size tier | Fee per unit |
|---|---|
| Small standard (16 oz or less) | $1.50 |
| Large standard (21 lb or less) | $1.80 |
| Small and medium oversize (151 lb or less) | $2.65 |
| Large and special oversize (over 151 lb) | $4.10 |
No fee applies to units graded Unsellable. The Restore to New fee started September 30, 2026 for sellers already enrolled in Refurbishment.
Sell as Used excludes items under $10 and hazmat products. Expiration-dated, meltable, recalled and consumable products are also excluded, as are categories that cannot be sold used. If you sell dangerous goods, the FBA hazmat guide explains how Amazon classifies them. Grading and relisting can take up to three weeks and longer in holiday periods. Storage fees stop during evaluation and restart after relisting.
FBA Returns: Relisting Cost vs Disposal
A graded unit costs $1.50 to $4.10 to relist, depending on size. Removal or disposal is also charged per unit. For standard-size items it starts at $0.84 for units up to 0.5 lb (the rate since January 15, 2026) and rises with shipping weight.
By our comparison, disposal of a light unit can cost less than relisting, and a heavier unit can cost more to dispose of than to relist. A relisted unit can also sell, while disposal recovers nothing. Compare the two for your own sizes before choosing which ASINs to enroll. For Sell as Used, Amazon recommends enrolling inventory with an average selling price above $10 to keep transactions net-positive after fees. For stranded or aged inventory, the long-term storage fees guide covers removal options.
Liquidation is the third path for units no program takes. Amazon says liquidators pay a gross recovery value of about 5% to 10% of the average selling price. Amazon then deducts a 15% liquidations referral fee and a per-unit processing fee.
Units relisted through Sell as Used come back under one of four conditions: Used – Like New, Very Good, Good or Acceptable. The listing carries a condition note such as “original packaging” for Like New. Amazon’s examples include large cosmetic imperfections for Acceptable units that were repackaged. One seller posted in Seller Forums that Amazon restocked an opened medical device as new, so the seal and packaging rule is a sensible first rule to write.
Set Grading Rules Before 2026 Holiday Returns Arrive
Most items bought from November 1 through December 31, 2026 can be returned until January 31, 2027, or January 15, 2027 for Apple products. That covers FBA, seller-fulfilled and Amazon retail orders, so returns will keep arriving into the new year. A short list to work through now:
- List your top return ASINs from the FBA customer returns report.
- Write seal and accessory rules for those ASINs first.
- Decide whether to keep Restore to New on now that it carries a fee.
- Set your Sell as Used recovery percentages.
- Check your unfulfillable settings for units no program takes.
- In February, compare results in the FBA customer returns report and the Sell as Used report.
The help pages describe no report that shows whether a rule was applied to a specific return. Outcomes appear in the FBA customer returns report and the Sell as Used report.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I stop Amazon customized grading from letting returns be sold as new?
Add a seal and packaging rule for the ASIN and answer that it cannot be resold as new if only the seal is broken. Amazon treats the rule as guidance. Disabling returns evaluation is a separate setting: returns for those ASINs are marked defective and are not eligible for reimbursement if damaged, and Amazon’s page does not say it prevents resale as new.
What is Amazon customized grading in Seller Central?
It is a Seller Central setting that lets you provide your own criteria for how customer returns are evaluated for resale, covering seal, packaging, accessories, authenticity and functionality.
Does Amazon have to follow my customized grading rules?
No. Amazon considers your criteria alongside its standard process for the ASINs a rule covers, in applicable categories.
What happens to ASINs without an Amazon customized grading rule?
They continue through Amazon’s default grading unchanged.
Is FBA Grade and Resell the same as Sell as Used under customized grading?
Sell as Used is the new name for the service that grades and resells returns as used. Grade and Resell is now the program name that also includes Restore to New.
Does Restore to New cost anything now that customized grading is live?
Yes. Restore to New carries the $1.50 to $4.10 per-unit processing fee, charged once when a unit is relisted. For sellers already enrolled in Refurbishment it started September 30, 2026.
Can I upload Amazon customized grading rules for many ASINs at once?
Yes. A rule can cover all ASINs, a typed or pasted list, or a CSV template upload.
How long does Amazon take to grade and relist a return after customized grading?
Up to three weeks, and longer during holiday periods.
Seller Essentials Blog
More Amazon FBA guides from Seller Essentials
Customized grading is one of several recent changes to how Amazon handles FBA returns, fees and unsellable inventory. The Seller Essentials blog covers Amazon FBA fee updates, returns and removals, and the policy changes that affect third-party sellers.


